Ka Wai Ola - Office of Hawaiian Affairs, Volume 25, Number 6, 1 Iune 2008 — Plotting the future of Mauna Kea [ARTICLE+ILLUSTRATION]

Plotting the future of Mauna Kea

By Blaine Fergerstrūm Ka Wai ūla Staff Now that the first series of puhlie meetings is over, a draft management plan for Mauna Kea is expected to heeome available as early as October. In May, Ku'iwalu, a consulting firm contracted by the Office of Mauna Kea Management (OMKM), an arm of the University of Hawai'i, conducted a series of puhlie meetings to gather input on a proposed master plan for the suimnit of Mauna Kea Ku'iwalu principal Dawn Chang told about 50 attendees of a May 13 meeting at the Hilo High School cafeteria that the contents of a draft plan would be "dictated by the connnunity" and that the final plan would have to be "supported and comfortable" to the connnunity. A draft of the plan will be written only after the eommunity has had full opportunity to connnent, she said. As stated on its web site, www.kuiwalu.com, "Ku'iwalu is a consulting eompany that specializes in building connnunity support for eeonomie development projects." About 20 of the Hilo attendees gave connnent or testimony, many taking several turns at the microphone. Attendees were asked to connnent on four prevalent areas of puhlie eoneein for the sunnnit, including, "Do you believe that anyone who accesses the mountain should receive cultural and enviromnental orientation?" Reynolds Nāhokualaka'i Kamakawiwo 'ole, a kahuna, talked about the spirituality and sacredness of the smmnit. He suggested that a new visitor center be built at the junction of Saddle and Telescope roads, far helow the current center at Hale Pōhaku. He agreed that cultural and enviromnental training should be mandatory for anyone going up to the sunnnit. Meeting organizers and some attendees suggested incorporating an orientation similar to that held at the Arizona Memorial Center at Pearl Harbor. Two other meetings were also held May 6 in Waimea and May 7 in Kona. Besides gathering input, the meetings also sought to describe

the aim of the Comprehensive Management Plan. The plan comes as a result of a ruling by Third Circuit Iudge Glenn Hara in Hilo, who reversed a state Board of Land and Natmal Resources decision to grant a permit allowing the construction and operation of the Outrigger Telescopes on the summit of Mauna Kea. The CMP is a precondition to granting a permit for any futme development in the Mauna Kea Science Reserve, an area whieh is leased to the University of Hawai'i. Currently, 11,000 acres of ceded land around the suimnit are leased to the Mauna Kea observatories for $1. Moanike'ala Akaka, a fonner Office of Hawaiian Affairs Trustee, railed about the $1 rent. "Fortyseven million Americans have no heahh insmance. UH should provide millions to the poor for heahh insurance." She asserted that if UH ean afford hundreds of millions of dollars for a telescope, UH could afford to pay fair market value for the land. Sanford Kahaia agreed, saying that fair compensation should be paid to beneficiaries of the ceded lands atop the mountain. He also said that unfettered access to the

mountain needs to be discouraged. Peter Mills, chair of the anthropology department at the University of Hawai'i at Hilo worked at the adze quarries near the smmnit. He was appalled at finding the historic sites disturbed by visitors "piling up ko'i, taking pictures and desecrating the sites." He said he had found ko'i blanks piled up near the road, apparently abandoned by would-be thieves. Akaka asked why Ku'iwalu held this workshop while the issue was in court. On the question of cultural training for summit visitors, she said: "Isn't this a little 'ōkole-backwards? I think you're asking 30 years too late." Akaka complained that scientists and the DLNR had been damaging the mountain for decades, and asked, "When is enough, enough?" Kahalelaukoa Rice, a Gemini Telescope outreach assistant with 10 years' experience at the smmnit said that she cherished the mountain, "not only scientifically, but cultmally." She said that all scientists receive training and regard the mountain as sacred. Rice also pointed out that "King David Kalākaua in 1874 brought the first telescopes to Hawai'i." Kalākaua placed them on the lawn of 'Iolani

Palaee so that the citizens could observe the stars and planets. "I am a Hawaiian first, but Hawaiians were always scientists." Big Island Press Club president lohn Burnett charged the OMKM with attempting to restrict news coverage on the mountain. He presented a letter of complaint detailing five apparent attempts to cmtail news-gathering efforts by members of the press on or around Mauna Kea by the OMKM. "I originally sent this letter to Bill Stonnont (of OMKM) in Ianuary. I still haven't received a reply." OMKM representatives did not provide an explanation at the meeting. Mark McNutt called for OMKM to prepare an "exit plan" for the telescopes to be removed from Mauna Kea. Hank Hanalei Fergerstrom, from the Temple of Lono, wearing a "Pop the Pimples" T-shirt (alluding to the telescopes as pimples atop Mauna Kea), called for no further development of the smmnit of Mauna Kea. Fergerstrom, who is a second cousin to this reporter, said that there was no need for a comprehensive plan. He said he deferred to a greater power, citing the U.S. Constitution, Hawai'i Constitution and Puhlie Law 103-

50, claiming his freedom of religion was being infringed by the further development of the smnmit. He asked, "Does it have to be western science?" Ioey Watts, a Mauna Kea tour guide and teacher at Waiākea High School, advocated inunediate action to protect the māmane trees and other endemic flora and fauna on the mountain. "They should put a fence around all those trees and elean the ground underneath" to remove invasive species. He suggested reforestation of māmane and koa forests on lands stripped by grazing animals. OHA Trustee Walter Heen attended the Hilo meeting and was recognized as the first Interim Director of the OMKM. Ku'iwalu has also conducted several months of "talk story" sessions with mukiple groups and has gathered a wide range of input for possible inclusion in a draft plan, whieh they project will be available for review in October or November. They plan to present the draft plan for consideration to the Board of Land and Natmal Resources in December. Comment ean be submitted at any time and the draft progress ean be monitored at the Mauna Kea Comprehensive Master Plan web site, www.maunakeacmp.com. ^

NŪ HOU - NEWS

h I Moanike'alū Akoko, former OHA Trustee, shows her husbond's art as an illustration of Hawaiians ūs scientists at ū May 1 3 Mauna Keo Master Plan puhlie meeting in Hilo. Right: Dawn Chang, principal of Ku'iwolu, told attendees of the Hilo meeting that ū draft plan would be "dictated by the community." Photos: Blaine Fergerstrom